Lutz played in the inaugural season of the Australian Baseball League, suiting up for the Canberra Cavalry in 2010/11. The then-21-year-old batted .260 over 29 games while playing at first base and in right field. Lutz was teammates that season with fellow Cavalry import Didi Gregorius. At the time, both were minor leaguers in the Reds organisation. In December of 2012, Gregorius was traded to the Arizona Diamondbacks. Promoted to the big leagues in mid-April, Gregorius is batting .407 through his first seven games with the D-Backs.
Lutz was signed by the Cincinnati Reds after being selected to attend the MLB International European Academy held in Tirrenia, Italy in 2006 and 2007.
The Major League Baseball International European Academy is designed to provide promising junior players with both the environment and the instruction to reach their full potential. Each summer, the European Academy brings together the brightest young playing talent in Europe and Africa with the best in Major League coaching and instruction. The Academy seeks to provide a path for elite players from this region to improve their skills in preparation for the rigors of professional and international baseball. The first graduate of the European Academy to play in Major League Baseball was Alex Liddi of the Seattle Mariners who made his Major League debut in 2011.
In addition to helping these bright young stars develop their skills, the Academy enables MLB Clubs to scout the best future talent. As a result, 57 Academy graduates from 12 countries to date have signed professional contracts with 21 different MLB organizations. Of the 57 European Academy players who have been signed, 28 are still Active Players with their organizations.
Born in New York, Lutz and his family moved to Germany when he was a year old. He began playing baseball at 15 and attended the MLB supported training academy in Regensburg, Germany before attending the European Academy. Previous Major Leaguers born in Germany have been children of American military personal who were stationed in Germany.